The 8 best Italian restaurants in South Dakota

If you’re looking for authentic, local Italian cuisine in South Dakota, you may have to search a bit harder, as smaller, independent restaurants specializing in Italian food can be more difficult to come by in this area. That said, if you’re willing to go off the beaten path, you might just find a hidden gem serving up delicious, homemade pasta or hearty Italian dishes in a cozy, neighborhood setting. With this said, here are the top 8 Italian restaurants in South Dakota.

Rapid City:

  • Sabatino’s Italian Ristorante: Indulge in a multi-course culinary journey featuring imported Italian ingredients and an expansive menu of pasta, meat, and classic desserts like cannolis.


  • Roma Ristorante Italiano: Savor a delectable lunchtime experience with their daily specials, including bread, soup or salad, and generous portions. Every dish on the menu is a testament to Italian culinary excellence.


  • Nonna’s Kitchen: Immerse yourself in the warmth of a cozy atmosphere while enjoying authentic Italian homestyle cuisine prepared with love. The architectural and familial history intertwined with modern Tuscan influences creates a truly unique dining experience.


  • La Minestra: Experience the heart of Rome in Pierre with authentic Italian dishes served in a warm and inviting family-run atmosphere. Taste the true essence of Italian heritage and create unforgettable memories.

Sioux Falls:

  • Tomacelli’s Pizza & Pasta: A local favorite renowned for its delicious and affordable Italian fare. Whether seeking a hearty dinner or a casual bite, Tomacelli’s caters to every palate.


  • Craft Chop House & Lounge: Ideal for group gatherings, offering Italian appetizers and catering services for birthdays, corporate events, and more. Enjoy daily specials like Happy Hour, Pasta Tuesday, and Ladies’ Night.


  • Charlie’s Pizza: Step back in time to 1959 with Charlie’s Pizza, boasting vintage d├ęcor and art. Perfect for families with its arcade, this establishment offers a nostalgic pizza experience.


  • Gold Pan Pizza: A must-visit during the Sturgis Bike Rally, Gold Pan Pizza delights with its delectable pizzas and legendary pasties. Note its limited opening hours on Wednesdays and Fridays.